ChatGPT advises (if that is the right word) that “Having a Plan B provides a backup strategy in ca
se your primary plan encounters obstacles or doesn’t work out. It adds resilience and adaptability to your approach, increasing the likelihood of success in uncertain situations.” It is a way of coping with the inevitable challenges and crises that will occur in our professional working lives no matter how good we are at our jobs and despite our best efforts. A plan B or even a plan C as well enables the unexpected to be dealt with and managed.
I spent last week at a small flat we have in the South of France to tidy it and fix things after a season of holiday lets. Everything seemed to be in reasonably good order with nothing I could not fix or replace. Then I came to wash on the first morning to discover there was no hot water whatsoever. I am reasonably good at what the French call bricolage, do it yourself, but I could see nothing obviously wrong and realised this was beyond my capabilities. For a moment I panicked slightly as you can’t let a flat without hot water. Plan A – everything was working – went out the window. Then I calmed down and as plan B called a local handyman who had fixed the electric boiler before. He could come round the next day. As a further back-up, because I thought it was perhaps an electrical fault, and as a plan C I contacted a local electrician who could look at the problem later in the week. Fortunately the handyman was able to fix the hot water and my plan B worked.
See this blog Preparing for Problems: Five Reasons Why You Need a Plan B which says “When it comes to planning, whether it’s for a project, meeting, or proposal – you’re most likely going to spend a lot of time and effort getting Plan A right – this is, after all, what you actually want to be doing – but life does have a tendency to throw roadblocks up, and sometimes Plan A can fall apart – and if you don’t have a back-up ready, you’re going to be left floundering, with time, resources, employees, and budget all at risk whilst you regroup.” Its suggestions include:
- A Backup Plan Can Provide a Safety Net, Allowing More Freedom in Decisions
- Plan A is Often a Predictable Approach, Plan B Can Allow for Innovation
- Considering Different Angles Can Identify Business-Critical Operations
Blackberry founded by Mike Lazardis was incredibly successful at first, but in 2010 failed to recognise the potential of encrypted text messages which later became a huge business for WhatsApp. Then as a business it also failed to grasp the power of a computer in a phone with a touch screen and from 2011 to 2012 began to lose out to Apple and the now ubiquitous iPhone. It would seem that this hugely successful corporation failed to grasp when it was time to move to a Plan B.
This short blog The Importance of Plan B sums this up nicely observing that “Thomas Edison, inventor of the light bulb, failed over 600 times before he discovered the right combination of materials and designs that worked.” and commenting “Accepting failure (or a lack of success), enables you to learn and develop a Plan B. Continuing to pursue a doomed plan is the plot line for a tragic life, a frustrated career and business failures. Plan B’s are the plot lines of hero’s and happy endings.”
There is even a book on the topic Getting to Plan B: Breaking Through to a Better Business Model by John Mullins and Randy Komisar which, in the context of start-ups or a new business in an existing organisation, explains that “new businesses are fraught with uncertainty. To succeed, you must change the plan in real time as the inevitable challenges arise. In fact, studies show that entrepreneurs who stick slavishly to their Plan A stand a greater chance of failing-and that many successful businesses barely resemble their founders' original idea.”
Some argue that a plan B is distracting from your primary plan. See this TED article Why having a Plan B can sometimes backfire which says there is scientific support for the benefits of a Plan B but observes that “Some researchers have recently found that having a fallback, or even thinking through one, might actually make you less motivated to achieve your primary goal and thus end up impeding your performance.”
However, from my experience over a long professional career things don’t always work out and it is far better to be prepared for this. If you provide IT services you should almost always have a backup disaster recovery system. As this Forbes article Why You Should Create a Financial Plan B comments:
“It would be nice if everything in life went according to plan.
You get the job you want and never get fired. You meet the person of your dreams and never break up. Your spouse or parents live forever, or at least until age 100. Plus, you eat right daily, exercise consistently and never get sick or injured.
Sadly, we all know that life simply doesn’t work that way.”
This military blog about fitness Why There's Never a Good Excuse Not to Have a Plan B explains the approach the armed forces take “In the military, we called these contingency plans. Every phase of the mission had contingencies, and even our contingencies had contingencies. Even the best designed plans can get screwed up. That is life. With regards to your fitness, you need a contingency plan, or Plan B, when life gets in the way.”
This definitely applies in sport – as Serena Williams says “If Plan A isn't working, I have Plan B, Plan C, and even Plan D.”
I also like this quote from the New Zealand rugby player Filo Tiatia “Always have a plan B and C, because if it doesn't work out there are other things you can focus on. It's important to have a balance to your life, regardless of what you're doing. I've been playing at this level for a long time, but I've got interests outside of rugby, like my family and my children. They keep me sane.”
And the actor Dick Van Dyke sums this all up nicely “In general, things either work out or they don’t, and if they don’t, you figure out something else, a plan B. There’s nothing wrong with plan B.”
RSS Feed