My point is that the French have used two clever and elegant solutions to reduce the need to close all or part of their roads for works and to mitigate the delay when they do. In IT contract negotiations there can often be at best an “us and them” attitude and at worst a “World War 3” approach between the negotiating teams where the other party is seen as the enemy to be bested at all costs. This may not matter and can even be an effective approach if you are buying or selling standard low value hardware where cost, quality and delivery are the essential requisites. Hower IT service contracts for say outsourcing desktop services have many different challenges. The objective should be to deliver a service that meets and even exceeds the requirements of the buyer, and enables the supplier to make a reasonable return and enhance its position in the marketplace by achieving successful delivery. This requires the establishment of much more of a partnership type relationship between the parties, which I suggest should commence during the procurement and contract negotiation phase. Then when the parties encounter a difficult and seemingly intractable challenge on say the limit of liability provisions, they can work together to understand the problem and seek a mutually acceptable and creative resolution.
See this article Impasse Resolution: How to Negotiate Through a Deadlock which proposes that “negotiation is not a battle but a process” during which “deadlocks become less of a roadblock and more of a signal that strategy must shift. With the right mindset—anchored in preparation, patience, and the ability to reframe—deadlocks can strengthen relationships, reveal hidden value, and produce stronger, more lasting agreements.”It then proposes how to prepare for and deal with deadlocks suggesting this “requires strategy, creativity and patience.” It cites a diplomatic example “During the Cold War, negotiations over nuclear arms limitations repeatedly reached deadlock. Both sides viewed concessions as threats to national security. Progress only came when negotiators expanded the scope of talks, linking arms reduction to economic cooperation and verification protocols.” Key takeaways include:
- Deadlocks …. are natural phases of the negotiation process that create pressure for creative solutions.
- Preparation reduces the risk of stalemates and provides confidence when they occur.
- The best impasse resolution strategies involve reframing, asking new questions, introducing objective standards, and trading concessions strategically.
A useful technique is to park the problem issue and move onto agree other less controversial points. See this short blog Have You Reached a Negotiation Deadlock? Break Through with the Set-Aside Tactic which suggests “Whenever the other side insists on a number or an issue that deadlocks the negotiation, simply acknowledge the contractor’s position and suggest setting it aside for a while and moving on to other issues.”Agreement on smaller points often sets a better climate for tackling larger challenges.
Here are some other ideas for resolving a deadlocked negotiation.
- Prepare thoroughly before any engagement and anticipate likely stumbling blocks
- Get pre-approved governance for different negotiating positions
- Work out why there is an issue as opposed to focusing on what the difference is
- Online or in person abandon looking at words in the agreement, step back and brainstorm using a whiteboard to capture the essential differences and potential solutions
- Let the other side think they have come up with what is actually your idea for a resolution
- Have a breakout session limited to lawyers and contract advisers, who can use their professional relationship to explore ways forward
- Take a break and have a change of scenery – go for a walk in the park or to a coffee shop
- Appreciate cultural differences on global contracts that may be causing misunderstanding
- Have clear escalation routes which can be used to verify any potential solution
However, rather like where you place gas mains in roads, there is a more fundamental challenge in IT service contract negotiations. This is the focus on cost as the main driver for the procurement. See this Forbes article Outsourcing 2.0: How To Move Past The Flawed RFP Model which commences “Outsourcing is typically equated with cost savings, leading businesses to mistakenly conclude that the only thing they'll gain from working with an outsourcer is cutting costs and improving operational efficiency.”
This is then often associated with a tender process where the customer issues a very rigid RFP specifying not just the requirement but the solution in great detail. See this blog Dump the RFP to reap better outsourcing results where the buyer tells the supplier how to do the work – “A common pitfall is what University of Tennessee researchers have coined the Outsourcing Paradox — which is when a buying organization procures goods or services from a supplier expected to be the expert and then tells them how to do the work. Innovation stagnates because specifics defined in the tender process restrain suppliers.”
Instead, it proposes a collaborative bidding process in which the purchaser of the services could raise:
- “A Request for Solution starts with the buyer coming to the table with background information, data, and characteristics of the existing environment, measurable outcomes, and an outline of the long-term vision.”
Or even more critically in an outsourcing context:
- “A Request for Partner layers in all the key collaborative features of the Request for Solution method but adds a critical dimension: It stresses the importance of finding a supplier that will be a good “fit” for their organization.”
Elegant and effective negotiation impasse solutions will work better, and indeed may only work at all, if the whole procurement climate is changed so the contract bid and negotiation process is based on a cooperative as opposed to an antagonistic price driven platform. Otherwise, we are likely to all be stuck in a “take it or leave it” world where the supplier is forced to drop out or accept a less-than-ideal solution – but ultimately it is the customer who suffers. The supplier on a cut price deal will seek to cut corners to reduce cost, service quality will go down - and if there is some delivery problem there is no relationship basis available to resolve this and costly litigation may ensue.
"The modern outsourcing relationship is no longer transactional. It is fundamentally relational and strategic."The author and businessman Thomas M. Koulopoulos.
"The best negotiations leave no winners or losers, only partners moving forward together." Vorng Panha a Cambodian legal scholar.
"You cannot shake hands with a clenched fist." Indira Gandhi.
RSS Feed